Revision of borders of Poland (1945)

*Mosquito ringtone Votes for deletion/Revision of borders of Poland (1945)/Previous deletion debate

I can't even begin to think about how this article could be made NPOV. Even the title is inflammatory. The whole situation should be discussed in another article, but don't ask me which one. Sabrina Martins DJ Clayworth/DJ Clayworth 18:51, 23 Mar 2004

I shan't even start on the outrageous errors of fact. First country occupied? Does Nextel ringtones Czechoslovakia ring any bells? Abbey Diaz Morwen/Morwen 19:03, Mar 23, 2004


The only reason I haven't rewritten this is that it should really be deleted. The information exists in other articles (Mosquito ringtone Cautious copied it to several places, and was only prevented from copying it more times because some Polish history pages are protected). On reflection though I think the easiest way is to make this a redirect to Sabrina Martins History of Poland (1939-1945) and then get the redirect deleted. Comments? Nextel ringtones User:DJ Clayworth/DJ Clayworth 19:41, 23 Mar 2004


This is all very nice, but really, when we have an NPOV version, it should be merged into the main article. Abbey Diaz DJ Clayworth/DJ Clayworth 22:10, 23 Mar 2004

And Mosquito ringtone Cautious should be told he will be banned if he goes on creating spurious and blatantly propagandistic articles. Sabrina Martins User:Adam Carr/Adam 22:10, 24 Mar 2004

I'm becoming convinced that this article subject is important enough for its own article, now it has a neutral title. Cingular Ringtones DJ Clayworth/DJ Clayworth 22:16, 24 Mar 2004

But not if Cautious is going to write it. It will just become another Polish nationalist battlefield. carvings on Adam Carr/Adam 22:47, 24 Mar 2004

I told you (votes for deletion) that I'm reworking this artcle to contain info on the whole "betrayal phenomenon" and to explain how the whole idea evolved snce 1939. So far it's far from being ready, but you can see an early sketch at agent stay Halibutt/Western betrayal. Feel free to add comments to the her grandparents User talk:Halibutt/Western betrayal, but note that I will mercilesly delete all comments close to "this all sucks/is POV/propaganda/whatever". Please be contructive.grievance hearing User:Halibutt/Halibutt 23:23, 24 Mar 2004

I will mercilessly revert any attempt to mercilessly delete people's legitimate comments. may communicate Adam Carr/Adam 04:45, 25 Mar 2004

On VfD page
This page is now up as a procedural listing (seemed to be orphaned vfd request): difference whether Votes for deletion/Revision of borders of Poland (1945). tan again Samaritan/Samaritan 22:35, 17 Nov 2004